Scanner or phone for old photos
In short: Under a hundred prints, use a phone; two thousand, use a scanner.
If you have twenty photographs, use a phone. If you have two thousand, and a scanner already in the cupboard, use the scanner. Between those, the decision is about time, not quality.
What each actually produces
A flatbed scanner at 600 DPI produces a file with more information than a phone can capture: real 600 DPI, no perspective error, no reflection, dust visible and removable.
A phone in daylight produces roughly 300–400 effective DPI over the print area at typical hand-held distances — enough for a full page in a book at 300 DPI, and better than a scanner used badly.
The difference you can see at print size is small. The difference you can see in the workflow is large.
When the scanner wins
- Volume. Two thousand prints on a phone at twenty seconds each is eleven hours of standing at a window. A scanner with an auto-feeder does it in an afternoon while you do something else.
- Slides and negatives. A phone cannot invert a negative properly. Either use a scanner with a transparency unit, or send the batch to a service.
- Fragile or badly damaged prints. A scanner's straight-on light flattens curl, so a creased photograph copies better flat than held in the air.
- Documents. Certificates, letters, certificates of employment — text scans sharper than it photographs.
When the phone wins
- Under a hundred prints. Setting up a scanner, finding the cable, installing the driver and cleaning the glass takes longer than the job.
- Albums you can't take apart. A magnetic album photographed in place is a copy; an album forced through a scanner is a damaged album.
- Anything larger than the platen. A3 portraits and panoramic prints do not fit an A4 scanner, and stitching two halves is worse than one clean phone shot.
- Away from home. Most of the photographs you'll want are in someone else's house.
The cheap hybrid
Scan the difficult ones, photograph the rest. If a scanner is available for one afternoon, use it for: negatives, slides, anything torn, anything that will be enlarged beyond a full page, and any document.
Then photograph the ordinary prints in batches of twenty at a window. The phone method is written out step by step.
What resolution to choose
- Prints up to 8 × 10: 600 DPI is plenty; 1200 DPI is a waste of disk.
- Slides and negatives: 1200–2400 DPI, because the frame is small.
- Documents: 300 DPI color, or 600 DPI black and white for text.
Save as TIFF if you have the space and JPEG at maximum quality if you don't. Do not save as JPEG twice — every re-save loses detail permanently.
What nobody tells you
The glass. A scanner with a dusty platen adds a soft haze to every file, and nobody notices until they compare. Clean it with a lint-free cloth before a big batch, and clean the underside of the lid too.
And keep the originals. Whatever you scan, the paper is still the source: what the archive needs.
We do the tedious part. The memory is yours. Why we built it