Using a scanning service
In short: Above roughly 500 prints or 100 slides a service makes sense.
At some volume, doing it yourself stops being the cheap option. A scanning service is worth it when the count is high, the formats are awkward, or the deadline is real.
When a service is the right answer
- More than about 500 prints, or more than 100 slides/negatives.
- Mixed formats: slides, negatives, large format, documents all in one box.
- Nothing to scan with. No scanner, no daylight window, no spare table for a month.
- A deadline with no slack. A reunion in three weeks is a service job, not a DIY job.
When it isn't
- Under 200 prints. DIY at a window takes a few evenings and costs nothing. The method.
- You want control over the crop. Services crop, straighten and color-correct by default, usually well, occasionally badly.
- Originals are fragile or mixed with documents. A service will handle them, but you'll worry for six weeks.
What to specify in the order
This is the part people get wrong, and it's unrecoverable afterwards.
- Resolution. 300–400 DPI for prints at print size; 1200–2400 for slides and negatives. Ask for "at least 300 DPI at the physical size of the print".
- Format. TIFF if offered, otherwise JPEG at maximum quality. Never accept a JPEG that has already been resized for web.
- No cropping. Say it in writing. Automatic crop software trims the white border, and sometimes trims the subject.
- No auto-enhance. Ask for "color and density correction only, no retouching".
- Naming. "Year-sequence" or "surname-year-index" if they'll do it; numbered otherwise, and you rename later.
- Delivery. An external drive you own, not a link that expires in 30 days. If a download link is the only option, download it the day it arrives and copy it twice.
- Originals returned, tracked, insured, and in the same order they were sent.
Ask these three questions before paying
- What happens to the originals while they're with you, and how are they shipped back?
- Is the resolution measured at the print's size or at the file's pixel dimensions? (The first is what matters.)
- Can I see ten sample files before the batch runs?
The third question is the one that saves money. Ten samples reveal the crop, the color and the sharpening before you've paid for two thousand.
Prices, roughly
Scanning services price per image, and the per-image rate drops sharply above a few hundred. Slides and negatives cost more than prints. A courier both ways plus the scan often lands at a noticeable multiple of a DIY evening's work — which is fine, if the DIY evening isn't going to happen.
The part nobody quotes for
Sorting. A service scans what you send, in the order you send it. If the box arrives as nine hundred unsorted prints, you get nine hundred unsorted files, and the sorting is still yours. How to sort first, so the files come back in an order you can use.
Afterwards
Everything scanned is an archive; thirty chosen photographs with captions is a book. The book is the part that gets looked at, and it's the part you can't buy from a scanning service.
We do the tedious part. The memory is yours. Why we built it