Sorting a box of family photos
In short: Three piles, pencil on the back, digitize before you organize, one working folder, and the three end states a collection can aim at.
Most family photo collections are not collections at all. They are a box, plus two envelopes, plus whatever survived a move in 2004. Nothing in it is labelled, and every attempt to "sort it out" ends after forty minutes with the box closed again.
The way out is not better storage. It is a smaller first step.
Sort into people and decades, not into themes
Empty a shoebox onto a table. Make three piles:
- People. Anyone you can name goes in one pile — grandmother, the uncle who died young, the neighbour's children.
- Places and things. Houses, streets, a car, a shop, a view.
- Everything else. Blurred frames, photos of nothing in particular, seventeen shots of the same mountain.
Pile three is the one to be honest about. It is not worthless — a blurry photo of a street can date other photos — but it does not belong in a book. Put it in a labelled box and stop worrying about it.
Write on the back before you forget again
Pencil, not pen. Soft pencil survives decades and can be erased; ballpoint bleeds through and ink from a felt tip will eventually transfer to the photo underneath.
Write three things where you know them: who, roughly when, where. "A-Gong, 1961, East Gate shop" is enough. For an unknown face, write what you know plus where it came from — "probably mother's sister, from the tin box" — and never leave it blank. A blank caption stays blank; a labelled guess can be corrected by somebody's aunt in five years.
Write along the edge, not across the middle of the image, and never press hard enough to emboss the front.
Digitize before you organize, not after
The order matters. Sorting an un-digitised collection means handling every print repeatedly, which is exactly how corners get bent and how the pile gets dropped.
Photograph each print once, name the file while the print is in your hand, then put the print back in its pile. How to do that with just a phone is written out step by step — daylight, phone parallel to the print, one photo at a time.
A naming scheme that still works in ten years: year-surname-event-01. "1963-weng-wedding-01" sorts correctly, searches correctly, and tells you what it is without opening it.
Keep one working folder, not twelve
Put the digitised files in one folder per decade or per person. Not both. Choose one axis and stay with it — mixed schemes are how people end up with four folders called "old photos".
Back up twice, in two different places, and check every few years that the files still open. Family archives are lost to unreadable disks far more often than to fire.
Decide what the collection is for
A sorted archive with no purpose stays a sorted archive. The reason to sort it is usually one of three: a book for someone, a display at a funeral or a birthday, or a permanent family archive for the next generation.
Each has a different end state:
- A book needs two to six dozen photographs around one axis — one person, one year, one place. That is what a photo book holds, and the rest of the collection stays in the archive where it belongs.
- A display needs large prints of six to ten photographs and no captions longer than a line.
- An archive needs everything, labelled, backed up, and nothing thrown away.
Do not aim at all three at once. Pick one, finish it, then come back.
What not to throw away
Old prints, negatives, and album pages with handwriting on them. Even a badly damaged print can carry information — the back, the border, the date stamp — that no digital copy has. Storage is cheap; the original is not reproducible.
The words that matter are the ones we will not write for you. How the arrangement works