A book about siblings
In short: Same three questions asked separately, equal photograph counts per sibling, chapters ordered by decade rather than by person, and no page about the inheritance.
You are sitting on the stairs of the old house, looking at a box of photographs, and your brother is in the kitchen asking where you put the camera. A book about siblings is a book about one house, seen from several directions at once. The photographs are similar; the accounts are not.
One page per sibling, same three questions
Ask each sibling the same three questions, separately, and print their answers without reconciling them:
- What do you remember about this room, in one paragraph?
- What did the family argue about?
- What did nobody else know at the time?
The third question is where the book gets good, and where you have to decide, later, what to print. Ask it before you decide.
The photographs to include
- One corner of the house, photographed once per sibling — each in the place they claimed as theirs. Sibling books live and die on this recognition.
- One photograph per person per decade. If one sibling has eight and another has two, the book will be read as a verdict about who was loved more. Fix that with a scanner, not with a caption.
- The group photographs, including the bad ones. The one where everyone is squinting is the one that gets talked over.
- The parents, young. Siblings are interested in their parents as people in a way that no other audience is.
Handle the asymmetry
Somebody has the photographs. Somebody else has the memory. Somebody third refuses to participate.
Practical answers:
- Ask the holder for files, not for originals, and name them by year. How to ask.
- Record the one with the memory on a phone, in twenty-minute sessions. How to do that.
- For the one who refuses: include their photographs anyway, and leave the page for their words blank with a line that says "not written by the family member concerned". That line is honest and it prevents the book being about an absence.
Structure
This is not a one-time thing — you can make one for each reunion, and add to them as the years go by. Three to five chapters, ordered by decade rather than by sibling: the house, the 1970s, the years away, the returns. Ordering by person turns the book into a competition with chapters; ordering by time keeps it a family.
When the photographs are scattered across five phones, Pianyu can arrange what you collect; the words stay yours. Forty to sixty photographs, chapter text of two to four hundred words — that's a chronicle.
What to leave out
The inheritance. The wedding nobody was invited to. Anything where printing it would start a fight at the next gathering.
The rule: a book can contain a disagreement about who was nicer to the dog, and cannot contain a disagreement about money.
One honest page
Near the end, a page with the same question answered by everyone: "what was the best year in this house?" Print four different answers side by side, no conclusion. That page is the reason siblings keep the book.
The words that matter are the ones we will not write for you. Why we built it