Pianyu

A partial record is still a record

In short: Number the grid, collect names position by position from two people, write what you do know, and mark the unknowns honestly instead of guessing.

When the names are gone, caption the photograph with what you still know and mark the gaps honestly. A partial record is a document; an invented one is a liability.

Number the grid, not the people

Draw the class photograph as a grid - rows and columns - and number the positions. Then collect names position by position from two independent people. Where they agree, write it down; where they disagree, put both names with a question mark. Never guess a name to fill a row.

What you can still caption without names

Four things survive even when every name is lost:

  1. Year, school, class - from the uniform, the building, the hair.
  2. The teacher, if you remember them.
  3. One fact about a position: "the boy in row two, second from left, who lent me a pen at every exam."
  4. What the day was: the first day, the last day, the photograph after the results.

A caption made of these is honest and readable. "Unidentified, third from left, possibly the boy who..." is a legitimate caption.

The two-verifier method, concretely

Print two copies of the numbered grid. Give one to each verifier and ask them to fill names without talking to each other. Compare afterwards: matching entries are settled, disagreements are marked with both names, blanks stay blank. Forty minutes, and the book stops encoding one person's confident mistakes.

When the school kept an archive

Yearbooks, class registers and the school's own photograph collection are the fastest route to names. Ask the office, not the alumni group: the office has the register with full names, the alumni group has the nicknames. Use the register for spelling, the group for the name people actually used.

Photographs with no people in them

The building, the corridor, the empty room on the last day - these need no names, and they are often the pages people linger on. Caption them with the year and one fact: "the corridor where the radiators knocked, photographed the week before the demolition." A photograph without people is a rest between two crowded pages.

The roster page

If you have a partial list, put it on its own page rather than under the photograph: a numbered roster with question marks where the name is unknown. Readers can add to it later; the book stays open to correction instead of pretending to be complete.

The photograph of people who are gone

If someone in the photograph has died, do not annotate it on the group page unless their family has agreed. Put the fact in your own memory page instead. A group photograph should be the year, not a casualty list.

Nicknames

Use the name that people actually used, and ask three people before printing it. Nicknames that were cruel in 1985 are still cruel in print; if it was a nickname someone did not choose, leave it out.

What to do with the single photograph where you only know two names

Make it a page about the two names: "In this class photograph I can identify two people: the teacher and the girl in the second row who lent me her notes for a year." That is a page with a story; the other twenty faces are the background, and background is fine.

What not to do

Do not guess. Do not write invented professions or invented deaths. Do not let one confident person supply all the names without checking - confidence and accuracy are different things. Do not caption from the back of the photo alone; handwriting on old prints is often the previous owner's, not the subject's. When in doubt, write "unidentified"; a blank is better than a wrong name.

What we make, precisely

A PDF: US Letter, 300 DPI, 3 mm bleed, one or two photographs per page, captions you write, automatic layout, 24-120 pages. Photographs stay on your device. Scanning class photographs, a school book for someone who hated school.

Make this book from your photos →Free to lay out the first 5 pages. Photos stay on your device.

One year is enough to make the first volume. How the arrangement works