Pianyu

How to choose twenty-four photographs

In short: A four-pass method for choosing the twenty-four photographs that become a family book: one container, the change pass, ordinary pages, and the final cut.

A family book fails at the choosing stage, not the printing stage. Most people start with four hundred photographs, get tired, and either give up or include everything. Twenty-four is a better number than four hundred, because it forces a decision and a decision creates a book.

This is a method for choosing those twenty-four.

Start with a container, not a pile

Before you open the camera roll, decide what the book is about. The container is what makes the choosing possible:

A container is not a theme. "Family" is a theme; "the kitchen on Sunday mornings" is a container. Containers have edges, and edges make choosing possible.

The four passes

Do not choose in one pass. Choose in four, and let the pile get smaller each time.

Pass one: the people pass

Pull every photograph that contains the person or the place the book is about. Do not judge quality. Aim for sixty to a hundred. This is the only pass where you are allowed to be generous.

Pass two: the change pass

From that pile, keep the photographs where something changed: a haircut, a house before and after, a new baby, a hospital discharge, a move. Change is what makes a sequence feel like a story.

Pass three: the ordinary pass

Add the photographs that show nothing important: the table, the car, the dog, the garden. These are the pages people stop on. Aim for eight to ten of them.

Pass four: the cut

You should now have forty to sixty. Cut to twenty-four by asking one question per photograph:

Would anyone in the family stop on this page, or turn past it?

If the answer is "turn past", cut it. If two photographs show the same thing, keep the one that is less flattering and more specific.

What to cut first

Sequencing: the shape matters more than the order

Twenty-four photographs do not need to be chronological. They need a shape:

  1. Open with a place or a face. Something the reader recognizes immediately.
  2. Middle: change. The years where something happened.
  3. End with an ordinary present. The most recent photograph should be unremarkable; it should say "this is still going".

If you are making the book as a gift, put the oldest photograph at the front and the newest at the back. The gap between them is the book.

Captions: one line, honest

Write the caption after the sequence is fixed, not while choosing. A caption should add what the photograph cannot show:

Do not write what is visible. Do not invent dates. If you are unsure, write "I think".

A note on permission

For photographs of adults, ask. For children, ask their parents. If the book contains a photograph someone dislikes, take it out. The book is not worth a family argument.

What the book should look like

A quiet layout: one or two photographs per page, generous margins, a single line of text. The design should not compete with the photograph. If the layout is interesting, the reader notices the layout; if it is quiet, the reader notices the photograph.

If you want the page-count arithmetic, how many photographs a book holds goes through it. If you are choosing photographs for a gift deadline, the Christmas memory book is the same method with a date attached. And if you are still deciding what to write, what to write under a photograph is the companion piece.

FAQ

Is 24 photographs enough for a book? Yes. Twenty-four photographs with captions is a real book — roughly forty-eight pages with front matter and chapter breaks. Fewer is also fine.

Should I include photographs where people look bad? Include the specific, unflattering, ordinary ones. Leave out the ones the subject hates. Specificity is not the same as unkindness.

Chronological or thematic order? Chronological is easier to make; thematic is easier to read. For a first book, choose chronological and put the ordinary present at the end.

Can I use photographs from different phones and cameras? Yes. The book is not a portfolio; mixed quality is part of the archive. Keep the largest file you have and do not upscale.

Make this book from your photos →Free to lay out the first 5 pages. Photos stay on your device.

We do the tedious part. The memory is yours. Why we built it