Pianyu

Five questions, one room

In short: The hardest week, what changed in the house, who was missed, what was dropped, what to keep - five questions, asked one at a time, turned into five pages.

Year-end questions work because the year is closing: five questions, asked one at a time, produce more than fifty questions asked at dinner. The deadline does the work that enthusiasm cannot.

Five questions, not fifty

Ask these five of one person - a parent, a grandparent, a partner - and stop:

  1. What was the hardest week of this year, and why?
  2. What changed in the house without anyone deciding it?
  3. Who did you miss?
  4. What did you stop doing this year?
  5. What do you want to keep doing next year?

Five questions, ten minutes each. The answers are the book.

Why these five

They avoid the two failures of family interviews: "tell me about your life" (too large) and "what's your best memory" (produces a performance). These questions are specific, they are about the recent past, and they allow a person to be sad without being asked to be sad.

Ask one at a time, in a room

Send the questions before you meet, but ask them one at a time. Ask the first, wait, and let silence last longer than feels comfortable. Do not correct facts; if a date is wrong, write it down as they said it and check later. Do not fill pauses with your own memories - the pause is where the answer is.

Record, then transcribe only what matters

Record on a phone, flat on the table, one voice and no fan. You do not need a transcript of everything; you need the five answers. Keep the audio anyway - the voice is the part nobody can reconstruct.

Turning answers into a book

One page per question: the answer in the person's own words, two or three sentences, and one photograph from that year. Five questions, five pages, plus a title page and a closing photograph - a 16 to 24 page book that takes one evening to lay out.

The family version

Send the same five questions to four households. Each returns five answers and one photograph; the book becomes a year seen from four angles. Where answers disagree - and they will - keep both. A family book that smooths disagreement reads like a card; one that keeps it reads like a record.

What to do with the answers if you are not making a book

Keep them in one document, dated, with the person's name. Twenty years from now that document will be worth more than the photographs, and it takes ten minutes to secure now. The book is a good container; the document is the asset.

If the person is in a care home

The five questions work better there, not worse: the year is smaller, the visits are regular, and the same questions can be asked again next year. Sit at the side, not across a table, keep the phone flat between you, and do not ask the hardest-week question if the year included a bereavement.

When to stop asking

Ten minutes per question is plenty. If the person is repeating themselves or tiring, stop and leave the rest for next year - the questions are designed to be reusable, and a partial answer kept is worth more than a complete one that exhausted the person. Say when you will come back with the next question.

What not to do

Do not turn this into a ninety-minute interview. Do not ask "what are you grateful for" - it invites a performance. Do not post the answers publicly without asking. Do not ask a grieving person the hardest-week question in the first year; use the other four.

What we make, precisely

A PDF: US Letter, 300 DPI, 3 mm bleed, one or two photographs per page, captions you write, automatic layout, 24-120 pages. Photographs stay on your device. A book for a parent who says there is nothing to tell, letters to your children.

Make this book from your photos →Free to lay out the first 5 pages. Photos stay on your device.

One year is enough to make the first volume. How the arrangement works